icarus's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Food Collab]

Awesome!

Very entertaining, straight up.

Some clips were sub-quality but i've made a collab and thats almost impossible to avoid.

Loved the gaybar music bit ahahhahah.

Well done on such an original concept....hope to see more...and maybe help out next time.

TheBoogley responds:

Thanks icarus, you'd be more than welcome to take part if I were to make another one.

[Escape Film Thing]

Awesome

Im not a fan of the clock crew...i really don't get it, but that was so damn well done....and funny!
Loved it...loved the prison break stuff....loved the pulp fiction bit at the end....make more pleeeasssee

biblo responds:

well... since you said please.. we'll get right on it poste haste!!

also watch more clock movies

[The One Layer Collab]

The thing I don't get...

Who cares if it's made on one layer?
I mean..it's like walking around with your eyes closed and saying 'look at me I can almost walk straight" or you could open your eyes and run....
My point being, you've got a great piece of software and your making sub standard animation and passing it off under the premise that its made in one layer...big whoop!
Use as many layers as you want and make something decent.
Besides that the whole thing was just pointless...a few random animations thrown together..i mean collabs are great when done properly..but why dont i just grab a few animations out of the portal, stick em together and call it a collab? Is that really a collab..i don't think so.

So..my advice...use some layers, have some connection between all the animations and make something awesome.

And yes..thats only my opinion.

MarcyVF responds:

Well, then the whole point of this collab would be lost. Have you ever tried to make something in one layer? It's quite a challenge. This is the first movie I've ever made in one layer, if you don't like it, go watch the other 29.

.M.

[(Biology Robots)]

hmmm....

Sorry, i'm still trying to work out how this got 3.18.
You said it yourself......this isn't for newgrounds...and i don't believe you went on to say why the hell you submitted it...seriously?

hashbrown responds:

because if i spent time making something, for newgrounds or not ill submit it. besides i agree is weird it has a 3.18, but thats my fanboys fault ;)

[Accidentally in Love]

People must really like that song...

...because that's about the reason that i can see for it getting such a high score, it seemed a bit rough around the edges to me, but i guess it was original and had length....

Rudy responds:

Thanks

[Lamps]

Nice

I'm a huge fan of creepy stuff like this, im not sure about having a style so close in some ways to david firth, i mainly mean the walls and some other stuff, but besides that i really liked it, you managed to creep me out a bit, i actually liked the voice acting i think it did its job well, anyway yeh i liked it, hope to see some more from you. P.S the great storyline really helped to make it freaky.

illwillbill responds:

Actually, this is Tim Burton inspired. I don't like, watch, or follow any of David Firth's flash cartoons.
Heh. This is actually how I draw. =P

Thanks for the review though. ^^
I appreciate all the comments I've been receiving on this. It's rare that I submit something that gets positive feedback like this.

[-MASS-]

Hmm...

I don't really agree with the message, just because a flash has blood and sex in it is no gaurantee that is going to be accepted, most of the flash that is "ignored" is just plain crap.
If someone is good, they will be recognised, so as for everyone saying what a great message, it really wasn't that great.

ZekeySpaceyLizard responds:

Incorrect.
There is a reason the majority of high scoring flash is ridiculously violent stick-figure cartoons and hentai sex games.
And its not because they're well made.

[eBaums world dot com]

Great flash.

I'm not disputing the fact that you can make money form stealing flash, or that it was done, but i had a look and everything seems to be linked back to the origional author, what exactly has he stolen?

altffour responds:

95% of the content on his site.

Unless since this flash came out he started giving credit, I'll never know because I'm never going back there.

[Squibblez - Hill]

Well..

Great idea, however i didn't really like the drawings- which is only me.
The one thing i can say for sure though is that the dialogue could have been presented in a more interesting way, it was just a bit plain and effortless.
Overall - nice.

Doink14 responds:

plain and effortless kindaof suited it tho, i dont think it would look rite with lots of colour and complex looking characters.

[F.B.F Randomness Remixed]

what are you reviewers on?

"One of the finest FBF flashes on NG"? what the hell??? Maybe you don't realises but FBF doesnt mean 5 minutes of dots chasing eachother around a screen with absolutely no point to it at all.
Oh yeh, i almost forgot, this has been done and done and done before.

rambo-16-89 responds:

yep i see your point

this was made for fun